al. Grunwaldzka 87/91 lok. 10, 80-244 Gdańsk +48 790 377 775 [email protected]
EN English

Representation before public authorities – URE, KOWR, KAS, KNF, UTK

We represent businesses in administrative and tax proceedings and during inspections – before the President of URE, KOWR, KAS authorities, KNF and the President of UTK, and subsequently before the courts.

A fuel trading licence, consent to acquire agricultural land, a railway licence, a customs and tax audit, a financial penalty imposed by a regulator – in matters like these a business is not in dispute with another company, but with a state authority that itself conducts the proceedings, gathers the evidence and issues the decision. They are governed by procedural rules that can be counter-intuitive for anyone outside the legal profession: short deadlines, the obligation to exhaust remedies, different appeal routes for different authorities. On this page we describe how such proceedings work in practice and how we can help.

We represent businesses and individuals before the President of the Energy Regulatory Office (Prezes Urzędu Regulacji Energetyki, URE), the National Support Centre for Agriculture (Krajowy Ośrodek Wsparcia Rolnictwa, KOWR), the bodies of the National Revenue Administration (Krajowa Administracja Skarbowa, KAS), the Polish Financial Supervision Authority (Komisja Nadzoru Finansowego, KNF) and the President of the Office of Rail Transport (Prezes Urzędu Transportu Kolejowego, UTK), and subsequently before the administrative courts and the Court of Competition and Consumer Protection (Sąd Ochrony Konkurencji i Konsumentów, SOKiK).

When it is worth having an attorney

Not every matter before a public authority requires an advocate. A business can often file a simple application with a complete set of documents on its own. An attorney is usually needed when:

  • the authority has opened proceedings of its own motion that may end with a financial penalty, the withdrawal of a licence or a tax decision,
  • an audit or inspection begins – a tax audit, a customs and tax audit or an inspection by a regulator,
  • the authority has requested that an application be supplemented or explanations be provided, and it is not clear how to respond without harming the case,
  • a decision has been issued refusing an application or imposing an obligation, and the deadline for an appeal is running,
  • the administrative matter is linked to a risk of fiscal penal liability or to a large transaction (e.g. the purchase of agricultural property or of shares in a company).

The sooner an attorney becomes involved, the more they can do. In administrative and tax proceedings, the evidence is gathered primarily before the first-instance authority. As a rule, the administrative court reviews the lawfulness of the decision on the basis of the case file – it does not take evidence afresh.

Administrative proceedings step by step

Most matters before public authorities are conducted under the Code of Administrative Procedure (Kodeks postępowania administracyjnego, k.p.a.), and tax matters under the Tax Ordinance (Ordynacja podatkowa). Specific statutes (e.g. the Energy Law, the Rail Transport Act) introduce their own exceptions. A typical sequence is as follows:

  1. Opening of proceedings – at the request of a party or of the authority's own motion. From this point it is worth notifying the appointment of an attorney. The power of attorney is granted in writing, and an advocate may certify a copy of it themselves (Article 33 § 2 and 3 k.p.a.; in tax matters – Article 138a of the Tax Ordinance).
  2. Investigative stage – the authority gathers evidence. A party has the right to participate actively at every stage of the proceedings (Article 10 § 1 k.p.a.), to inspect the case file and make copies of it (Article 73 § 1 k.p.a.), and to submit applications for evidence and explanations.
  3. Time limits for dealing with the matter – a matter requiring investigation should be dealt with within one month at the latest, and a particularly complex matter within two months (Article 35 § 3 k.p.a.), unless specific provisions provide otherwise. In the event of inaction or excessive delay, a party may file a reminder (ponaglenie) (Article 37 k.p.a.; in tax matters – Article 141 of the Tax Ordinance).
  4. Notice of the close of evidence-gathering – the authority gives the party an opportunity to comment on the material gathered. In matters initiated at the request of a party, the authority must indicate which conditions the party has not met or has not demonstrated (Article 79a k.p.a.). The Tax Ordinance provides for a seven-day period at this stage (Article 200 § 1). This is the last good moment to supplement the evidence.
  5. Decision – doubts as to the content of a provision, as well as doubts as to the facts that cannot be resolved, are, as a rule, resolved in favour of the party in matters imposing an obligation or withdrawing an entitlement (Articles 7a and 81a k.p.a.), subject to the exceptions set out in those provisions.
  6. Appeal – an appeal is lodged within 14 days of service of the decision, through the authority that issued it (Article 129 § 1 and 2 k.p.a.; in tax matters Article 223 of the Tax Ordinance). Against a first-instance decision of a minister or of a local government appeals board (samorządowe kolegium odwoławcze), instead of an appeal, an application for reconsideration of the matter may be filed (Article 127 § 3 k.p.a.). Specific provisions may provide for other deadlines and other appellate authorities.
  7. Complaint to the Voivodeship Administrative Court (wojewódzki sąd administracyjny, WSA) – after the remedies have been exhausted (Article 52 of the Law on Proceedings before Administrative Courts (p.p.s.a.)), within 30 days of service of the ruling (Article 53 § 1 p.p.s.a.), lodged through the authority (Article 54 § 1 p.p.s.a.). For authorities in our region, the court of first instance is usually the Voivodeship Administrative Court in Gdańsk (Wojewódzki Sąd Administracyjny w Gdańsku). Lodging a complaint does not in itself suspend enforcement of the decision (Article 61 § 1 p.p.s.a.) – a stay must be applied for.
  8. Cassation appeal to the Supreme Administrative Court (Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny, NSA) – within 30 days of service of the judgment with its statement of reasons (Article 177 § 1 p.p.s.a.). As a rule, it must be drafted by an advocate or a legal adviser (radca prawny) (Article 175 § 1 p.p.s.a.).

Besides this ordinary procedure, there are extraordinary procedures – the reopening of proceedings (Article 145 k.p.a.) and a declaration that a decision is invalid (Article 156 k.p.a.). They have closed lists of grounds and cannot make up for a late appeal.

President of URE – fuel licences and financial penalties

A licence is required for, among other things, trading in fuels (Article 32(1)(4) of the Energy Law (Prawo energetyczne) – with the exceptions listed in that provision) and for the storage and transhipment of liquid fuels. For the production of liquid fuels and for trading in liquid fuels with foreign countries, the Act requires financial security of 10,000,000 zł (Article 38a(1)).

In matters before the President of URE we assist with:

  • preparing an application for a licence or for a change to its terms – complete, with documents concerning technical, financial and staffing resources,
  • proceedings to change the terms of a licence or to withdraw it (Article 41 of the Energy Law),
  • proceedings concerning financial penalties (Article 56 of the Energy Law) – from the first request for explanations,
  • appeals against decisions.

Important: decisions of the President of URE are not challenged by a complaint to an administrative court. Instead, an appeal lies to the Regional Court in Warsaw (Sąd Okręgowy w Warszawie) – the Court of Competition and Consumer Protection – within 14 days of service of the decision, and against procedural decisions (postanowienia) an interlocutory appeal (zażalenie) lies within 7 days (Article 30(2) and (4) of the Energy Law). The proceedings are conducted under the Code of Civil Procedure (Article 30(3)). Choosing the wrong route or missing the deadline is one of the most serious mistakes in these cases.

KOWR – agricultural property

The Act on Shaping the Agricultural System (ustawa o kształtowaniu ustroju rolnego) restricts trading in agricultural property. Among other things, it does not apply to properties in which the area of agricultural land is less than 0.3 ha (Article 1a(1)(b)). For larger properties:

  • Who can buy – as a rule, only an individual farmer (rolnik indywidualny), and the area of the property acquired, together with the buyer's family farm, may not exceed 300 ha of agricultural land (Article 2a(1) and (2)). The Act provides for exceptions, e.g. acquisition by a person closely related to the seller (Article 2a(3)).
  • Consent of the Director General of KOWR – in other cases, the acquisition requires consent issued by way of an administrative decision, at the request of the seller or of a buyer who meets the statutory conditions (Article 2a(4)). The higher-level authority is the minister responsible for rural development.
  • Buyer's obligations – the buyer must run the farm for at least 5 years and during that time may not dispose of the property or hand over possession of it without the consent of the Director General of KOWR (Article 2b(1)–(3)).
  • Right of pre-emption – this is held by the tenant (where the lease has a certified date (data pewna) and has been performed for at least 3 years) and, subsequently, by KOWR (Article 3(1) and (4)). The time limit for exercising the right of pre-emption over real property is, as a rule, one month from notification (Article 598 § 2 of the Civil Code (k.c.)). If the price differs grossly from the market value, the party exercising the right of pre-emption may apply to the court within 14 days to have the price determined (Article 3(8)).
  • Shares in companies – KOWR has a right of pre-emption over shares in companies holding agricultural property of at least 5 ha, with 2 months to make its declaration (Article 3a).
  • Right of acquisition – where ownership is transferred otherwise than by sale (e.g. a gift or a contribution in kind), KOWR may make a declaration that it is acquiring the property (Article 4).

A transaction contrary to the Act – e.g. without notifying the holder of the right of pre-emption – is invalid (Article 9(1)). That is why we plan such transactions before the visit to the notary: we establish whether the Act applies, whether consent is required and how to structure the agreement. More about transactions on the real estate page.

National Revenue Administration – audits and tax proceedings

A tax audit (kontrola podatkowa, conducted by the head of the tax office) is, as a rule, preceded by a notice; the audit begins no earlier than 7 days and no later than 30 days after service of the notice (Article 282b § 2 of the Tax Ordinance). The course of the audit is documented in a report (Article 290). A taxpayer who disagrees with it may, within 14 days, submit objections or explanations together with applications for evidence; the absence of objections means that the audited party does not dispute the findings (Article 291 § 1 and 3). After the audit, the tax return may be corrected (Article 81b § 1(2)(a)).

A customs and tax audit (kontrola celno-skarbowa, conducted by the head of the customs and tax office) begins with the service of an authorisation (Article 62 of the National Revenue Administration Act (ustawa o KAS)). It ends with the service of the audit result (Article 82(1)). Within 14 days of its service, a tax return or a corrected return may be filed (Article 82(3)) – a later correction has no effect. If irregularities have been found and no correction has been filed, or it has not been accepted, the audit is converted into tax proceedings (Article 83(1)).

These 14 days are the moment for a strategic decision: whether to accept some of the findings and correct the return, or to challenge them. This also affects the fiscal penal risk – a legally effective correction of a tax return may exclude liability for an act relating to its filing (Article 16a of the Fiscal Penal Code (k.k.s.)). As a rule, a tax liability becomes time-barred 5 years after the end of the year in which the payment deadline expired (Article 70 § 1 of the Tax Ordinance), but the law provides for cases in which this period is suspended or interrupted. We describe fiscal penal cases on the Fiscal Penal Code page.

President of UTK and KNF

The President of the Office of Rail Transport grants, refuses, amends, suspends and withdraws railway undertakings' licences by way of administrative decisions (Article 45 of the Rail Transport Act (ustawa o transporcie kolejowym)). The Code of Administrative Procedure applies to the proceedings (Article 13a). In some market regulation matters (including access to infrastructure), an appeal against a decision of the President of UTK lies to the Court of Competition and Consumer Protection within 14 days (Article 13b(2)) – in other matters the administrative route applies. Before lodging a remedy, we always check which route applies to the decision in question.

The Polish Financial Supervision Authority conducts licensing, supervisory and sanction proceedings against entities in the financial and insurance markets. The procedure and the remedies depend on the statute under which KNF is acting in the particular matter, so we determine them separately in each case. We assist with applications, with responses to requests for information and in sanction proceedings.

Inspection of a business – what rights you have

Unless a specific statute provides otherwise, inspections of business activity are governed by the Entrepreneurs' Law (Prawo przedsiębiorców):

  • the authority gives notice of its intention to carry out an inspection, and the inspection begins no earlier than 7 days and no later than 30 days after service of the notice (Article 48(1) and (2)) – the law provides for exceptions to this,
  • inspection activities are, as a rule, carried out in the presence of the business owner or a person authorised by them (Article 50(1)),
  • the total duration of all inspections by one authority in a calendar year is limited and depends on the size of the business (Article 55),
  • an objection (sprzeciw) may be raised against activities carried out in breach of the specified provisions – within 3 working days (Article 59(1) and (4)).

During an inspection, it is worth appointing a single person to deal with the inspectors, keeping a list of the documents handed over and not making hasty oral explanations for the record. We can be present during the inspection activities and prepare objections to the report.

Administrative financial penalties

The Code of Administrative Procedure sets out general rules for imposing penalties, unless a specific statute regulates them differently. The authority must take into account, among other things, the gravity and circumstances of the infringement, its duration, previous infringements and the extent to which the party contributed to it (Article 189d k.p.a.). In certain situations, the authority refrains from imposing a penalty and confines itself to a caution (Article 189f). As a rule, no penalty is imposed if five years have elapsed since the infringement (Article 189g § 1). In penalty proceedings we seek to demonstrate mitigating circumstances and to gather evidence that the infringement has been remedied.

Most common mistakes

  • Missing a deadline – 14 days for an appeal pass quickly, and for decisions of the President of URE the route and deadlines differ from those in an ordinary administrative case.
  • An appeal without new arguments and evidence – the appellate authority reconsiders the matter, but only on the basis of what is in the case file.
  • No objections to the audit report – it is then assumed that the audited party does not dispute the findings.
  • A hasty correction of a tax return "for the sake of peace and quiet" – or, conversely, forgoing a correction that could have limited the fiscal penal risk.
  • Signing an agreement to acquire agricultural land without checking the statutory restrictions – this risks invalidity.
  • Conversations with the authority without notes – after a few months no one remembers what was agreed by telephone.

What you can do yourself, and where an advocate will help

You can yourself: collect correspondence and keep track of the dates of service (deadlines run from them), gather documents, inspect the case file and file a simple application. An advocate is needed especially for an appeal, a complaint to the court, objections to an audit report and penalty proceedings – and is mandatory for a cassation appeal to the NSA.

How we work

  1. Analysis – we review the decision, report or request and the case file, and establish the deadlines and the correct route of appeal.
  2. Plan – we tell you plainly what the arguments, risks and realistic scenarios are, including the costs of the proceedings.
  3. Action – we prepare the documents, take part in proceedings and inspections, and handle contact with the authority.
  4. Court – where necessary, we represent the client before the WSA, the NSA or SOKiK.

Our office is in Gdańsk on al. Grunwaldzka. We serve businesses from the Tricity and the whole of Pomerania – including Gdynia, Sopot, Pruszcz Gdański, Tczew, Starogard Gdański, Kartuzy, Wejherowo, Kościerzyna and Malbork. Since URE, KNF and UTK are central authorities, and SOKiK and the NSA have their seats in Warsaw, we also handle cases outside the Pomeranian Voivodeship. We describe the sector-specific aspects of transport and fuel cases on the transport law and the fuel sector page. A consultation can be arranged via the contact page.

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to appeal against a decision?

In ordinary administrative and tax proceedings – 14 days from service of the decision (Article 129 § 2 k.p.a., Article 223 § 2 of the Tax Ordinance). Specific provisions may lay down other deadlines – for example, an appeal against a decision of the President of URE is lodged with the court within 14 days, and an interlocutory appeal against a procedural decision within 7 days.

Does an appeal suspend enforcement of the decision?

In administrative proceedings, lodging an appeal within the deadline as a rule suspends enforcement of the decision (Article 130 § 2 k.p.a.) – unless it has been declared immediately enforceable or is immediately enforceable by operation of law (Article 130 § 3). It is different with a complaint to the administrative court – the complaint itself does not suspend enforcement of the decision; a stay must be applied for (Article 61 p.p.s.a.).

The authority has not responded for months. What can I do?

File a reminder (ponaglenie) with a statement of reasons (Article 37 k.p.a., in tax matters Article 141 of the Tax Ordinance). Once it has been filed, a complaint about inaction or excessive length of proceedings may be lodged with the administrative court (Article 53 § 2b p.p.s.a.).

During a customs and tax audit, do I have to give explanations straight away?

The content of explanations is worth thinking through – they go into the file and may also be used in fiscal penal proceedings. The key period is the 14 days after service of the audit result, during which a corrected tax return may be filed.

I am buying an agricultural plot. Do I need KOWR's consent?

That depends on the area of agricultural land, the status of the buyer and the manner of acquisition. The Act on Shaping the Agricultural System does not apply to properties with less than 0.3 ha of agricultural land. For larger properties, the buyer may, as a rule, be an individual farmer, and in other cases the consent of the Director General of KOWR is required. It is worth checking this before the preliminary agreement.

Is a decision of the President of URE challenged by a complaint to the WSA?

No. An appeal is lodged with the Regional Court in Warsaw – the Court of Competition and Consumer Protection (Article 30(2) of the Energy Law), and the case is conducted under the Code of Civil Procedure.

Can you take over a matter while the proceedings are under way?

Yes. An attorney can be appointed at any stage. In that case, we first check the case file and the deadlines that are already running.

Call: +48 790 377 775