al. Grunwaldzka 87/91 lok. 10, 80-244 Gdańsk +48 790 377 775 [email protected]
EN English

Commercial company law – company formation, shareholders' agreements, management board and disputes

We set up companies, prepare articles of association and shareholders' agreements, advise management boards and represent shareholders in disputes – over resolutions, leaving a company and the liability of management board members.

A commercial company is meant to separate private assets from business risk and to put relations between the shareholders in order – but it works the way it has been set up. Articles of association copied from a template, no rules on a shareholder's exit, a management board that does not keep track of KRS deadlines and does not respond to a loss of liquidity – these are situations in which limited liability stops protecting, and a conflict between shareholders can paralyse a business for years.

We help businesses at every stage of a company's life – from formation, through the day-to-day work of the management board and shareholders' meetings, to transformations and disputes. Below we describe the most important issues.

How we work with companies

  1. A conversation about the goal. We ask about the business model: who contributes money, who contributes work, who makes decisions, what the plans are (an investor, a sale of the business, succession).
  2. Analysis of documents. We check the articles of association or statute, the extract from the National Court Register (Krajowy Rejestr Sądowy, KRS), the share register or register of shareholders, resolutions and contracts with management board members.
  3. Drafting and implementation. We prepare documents and KRS applications, attend meetings at the notary's office and keep track of deadlines.

We can provide ongoing corporate services or handle one specific matter. The scope of work and the fee arrangement are agreed before the engagement begins.

Choosing the legal form and setting up a company

The Commercial Companies Code provides for seven types of commercial company. In practice, one of the following is most often chosen:

  • limited liability company (spółka z ograniczoną odpowiedzialnością, sp. z o.o.) – share capital of at least PLN 5,000, nominal value of a share at least PLN 50 (Article 154 k.s.h.); shareholders are not liable for the company's obligations (Article 151 § 4),
  • simple joint-stock company (prosta spółka akcyjna, P.S.A.) – share capital of at least PLN 1 (Article 3003 § 1), shares without nominal value, and a contribution may also consist of work or services (Article 3002 § 2); contributions must be made within three years of registration (Article 3009 § 1); instead of a management board and a supervisory board, a board of directors may be appointed (Article 30052),
  • joint-stock company (spółka akcyjna) – share capital of at least PLN 100,000 (Article 308 § 1),
  • general partnership (spółka jawna) – a partner is liable for the partnership's obligations with all of his assets, jointly and severally with the other partners and the partnership (Article 22 § 2), but a creditor may enforce against a partner's assets only once enforcement against the partnership's assets has proved ineffective (Article 31 § 1),
  • limited partnership (spółka komandytowa) – the general partner is liable without limitation, while the liability of the limited partner is limited (Article 102); the general partner is often a limited liability company.

S24 or a notary. The articles of association of a limited liability company are concluded in the form of a notarial deed (Article 157 § 2), but they may also be concluded using a template in the online system (S24), signed with a qualified electronic signature, a trusted profile signature or a personal signature (Article 1571). The same option exists for a general partnership (Article 231), a limited partnership (Article 1061) and a P.S.A. (Article 3007). The S24 procedure is quick and cheap but has limitations: in a limited liability company the capital is covered exclusively by cash contributions, made no later than seven days after entry in the register (Article 158 § 11), and the provisions of the template can be modified only to the extent provided for in the form. If the shareholders need a contribution in kind, preferential shares, restrictions on the transfer of shares or rules on leaving the company – a notarial deed is the better choice.

The period before registration. A limited liability company comes into existence upon entry in the register (Article 163(5)), and the company in organisation and the persons who acted on its behalf are jointly and severally liable for the obligations of the company in organisation (Article 13 § 1).

Articles of association and shareholders' agreement

The Code requires few elements in the articles of association of a limited liability company (Article 157 § 1). What really determines relations between the shareholders has to be added – we discuss, among other things:

  • the rules for appointing and dismissing management board members and their term of office (Article 201 § 4, Article 202),
  • matters requiring the consent of the shareholders' meeting or the supervisory board, including the threshold in Article 230 k.s.h. (obligations with a value exceeding twice the share capital),
  • restrictions on the transfer of shares – the company's consent, a right of first refusal (Article 182),
  • the rules for heirs joining the company or being bought out (Article 183),
  • redemption of shares, including compulsory redemption – possible only if the articles of association so provide and specify the conditions and procedure (Article 199 § 1),
  • distribution of profit other than in proportion to shareholdings (Article 191 § 2),
  • a supervisory board – mandatory only when the capital exceeds PLN 500,000 and there are more than twenty-five shareholders (Article 213 § 2).

A shareholders' agreement (investment agreement, agreement between shareholders) is a separate document binding the shareholders among themselves. It regulates what one does not want to disclose in the KRS or what cannot be included in the articles of association: a financing schedule, a non-compete clause, drag-along and tag-along clauses, call and put options, deadlock resolution mechanisms, contractual penalties. It is best to prepare both documents together.

The management board – duties and liability towards the company

In performing his duties, a management board member should exercise the diligence resulting from the professional nature of his activity and remain loyal to the company (Article 2091 § 1 k.s.h.). He is liable to the company for damage caused by an act or omission contrary to the law or the articles of association, unless he is not at fault (Article 293 § 1; in a joint-stock company Article 483 § 1, in a P.S.A. Article 300125).

Since 13 October 2022 the Code has expressly provided that a management board member does not breach the duty of diligence if – acting loyally towards the company – he acts within the limits of justified business risk, including on the basis of information, analyses and opinions that should be taken into account in the circumstances (Article 293 § 3, Article 483 § 3). In practice this means that protection comes from a documented decision-making process: management board resolutions, analyses, opinions of advisers. The company's claim for compensation becomes time-barred three years from the day on which the company learned of the damage and of the person obliged to remedy it, but no later than ten years from the event (Article 297).

Two pitfalls we often encounter: in a contract between the company and a management board member, and in a dispute with him, the company is represented by the supervisory board or by an attorney appointed by a resolution of the shareholders' meeting (Article 210 § 1), and where the sole shareholder is also the sole management board member, a transaction between him and the company requires the form of a notarial deed (Article 210 § 2).

Article 299 k.s.h. – liability for the company's debts

If enforcement against a limited liability company proves ineffective, the management board members are jointly and severally liable for its obligations (Article 299 § 1 k.s.h.; similarly in a P.S.A. – Article 300132). A management board member may be released from this liability if he shows that:

  • a petition for bankruptcy was filed in due time, or at the same time restructuring proceedings were opened or an arrangement was approved,
  • the failure to file the petition was not his fault,
  • despite the failure to file the petition, the creditor suffered no damage (Article 299 § 2).

"Due time" is determined by the Bankruptcy Law: the petition must be filed no later than thirty days from the day on which the grounds for declaring bankruptcy arose (Article 21(1)), i.e. insolvency (Article 10). Insolvency is presumed, among other things, where a delay in the performance of monetary obligations exceeds three months (Article 11(1a)). Failure to file the petition also carries criminal liability (Article 586 k.s.h.).

Similar liability applies to the company's tax arrears (Article 116 of the Tax Ordinance) and – through the reference in Article 31 of the Social Insurance System Act – also to ZUS contributions. We represent both creditors suing management board members and management board members – current and former – defending themselves. Where there are liquidity problems, it is worth talking to a lawyer before the thirty days have elapsed.

Resolutions and challenging them

A resolution of the shareholders' meeting that is contrary to the articles of association or to good practice and harms the interests of the company or is aimed at prejudicing a shareholder may be set aside by the court (Article 249 § 1 k.s.h.). A resolution contrary to statute may be declared invalid (Article 252 § 1). The deadlines are key:

  • an action to set aside a resolution – one month from receiving notice of the resolution, but no later than six months from its adoption (Article 251),
  • an action for a declaration of invalidity – six months from receiving notice, but no later than three years from the adoption of the resolution (Article 252 § 3),
  • in a joint-stock company, one month/six months and six months/two years respectively, with shorter deadlines in a public company (Articles 424, 425).

Not everyone can sue. A shareholder present at the meeting must vote against the resolution and demand that his objection be recorded in the minutes; an absent shareholder may challenge a resolution only if the meeting was improperly convened or the resolution was adopted outside the agenda (Article 250). If you expect a dispute, consult us before the meeting. Challenging a resolution does not suspend the registration proceedings (Article 249 § 2), so where necessary we also apply for interim relief.

A shareholder leaving the company

The way to leave depends on the type of company and on what the articles of association provide:

  • sale of shares – in a limited liability company the transfer agreement requires written form with notarially certified signatures (Article 180 § 1); if the articles of association make the transfer subject to consent and the management board refuses it, the registry court may permit the transfer for important reasons (Article 182 § 3),
  • redemption of shares – voluntary or compulsory, only if provided for in the articles of association; in a compulsory redemption the consideration may not be lower than the value of net assets attributable to the share according to the last financial statements (Article 199 § 2),
  • exclusion of a shareholder by the court – for important reasons, at the request of all the other shareholders whose shares represent more than half of the capital; the price for taking over the shares is set by the court according to their actual value on the day the statement of claim is served (Article 266),
  • dissolution of the company by the court – where achieving the company's objective has become impossible or other important reasons arising from the company's relationships have occurred (Article 271),
  • in a general partnership – termination of an agreement concluded for an indefinite period with six months' notice before the end of the financial year, in writing (Article 61), or a demand for dissolution of the partnership or exclusion of a partner for important reasons (Article 63); the value of the capital share is determined on the basis of a separate balance sheet taking into account the sale value of the partnership's assets (Article 65).

The cheapest exit is one that was planned in the articles of association or the shareholders' agreement before any conflict arose.

Corporate disputes

Disputes arising from the company relationship are commercial cases, as are cases concerning the liability of members of company bodies under Articles 291–300 k.s.h. (Article 4582 § 1(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure). Cases to set aside or declare invalid resolutions fall within the jurisdiction of the regional court (sąd okręgowy) regardless of value (Article 17(42) k.p.c.). We handle, among others, cases:

  • to set aside or declare invalid resolutions,
  • for compensation for damage caused to the company – if the company does not sue the perpetrator within one year of the act being disclosed, any shareholder may do so (Article 295 § 1; in a joint-stock company Article 486),
  • concerning access to information – a shareholder of a limited liability company may inspect the books and documents and demand explanations from the management board and, following a refusal, file an application with the registry court within seven days (Article 212),
  • for the return of payments made contrary to the law or the articles of association (Article 198).

In parallel with court proceedings we often negotiate a buyout of shares or a division of the business. More: litigation.

Transformations, mergers, divisions and groups of companies

Any commercial company may be transformed into another (Article 551 § 1 k.s.h.), and a civil-law partnership (spółka cywilna) into a commercial company other than a general partnership (Article 551 § 2). A transformation requires, among other things, a transformation plan and a resolution recorded in notarial minutes (Article 556, Article 562 § 2). The transformed company has all the rights and obligations of the company being transformed, including, as a rule, permits, licences and reliefs (Article 553).

A sole proprietorship (jednoosobowa działalność gospodarcza) may be transformed into a single-member capital company (Article 551 § 5) on the basis of a transformation plan in the form of a notarial deed, with an opinion of a statutory auditor (Articles 5845, 5846). For three years from the day of transformation, the entrepreneur is jointly and severally liable with the company for earlier obligations related to the business (Article 58413).

A merger takes place by acquisition or by the formation of a new company (Article 492 § 1). A division concerns capital companies and limited joint-stock partnerships, including by spin-off or separation of part of the assets (Articles 528, 529). A company in bankruptcy may not merge, divide or transform (Article 491 § 3, Article 528 § 3, Article 551 § 4).

Groups of companies (holding law). Since 2022 a subsidiary may, by a resolution adopted by a majority of three quarters of the votes, join a group of companies, which is disclosed in the register (Article 211 § 2–3). The parent company may then issue binding instructions to it – in written or electronic form on pain of invalidity, stating the group's interest and the way in which any damage will be remedied (Article 212) – and inspect its books (Article 216). The subsidiary must refuse to carry out an instruction that would lead to its insolvency or the threat of insolvency (Article 214 § 1), and the members of its bodies are not liable for damage caused by carrying out a binding instruction (Article 215 § 1).

KRS and reporting obligations

An application for registration of a change in the KRS is filed within 7 days of the event, unless a specific provision provides otherwise (Article 22 of the National Court Register Act), exclusively via the online system (Article 19(2)). If the company fails to file the application or documents, the registry court summons it with a 7-day deadline under threat of a fine, which it may impose repeatedly (Article 24). Failure to file financial statements for two consecutive years despite a summons may lead to proceedings being initiated ex officio to dissolve the company without liquidation (Article 25a(1)(4)).

Under the Accounting Act, the management board prepares the annual financial statements within 3 months of the balance sheet date (Article 52(1)), they are approved no later than 6 months after the balance sheet date (Article 53(1); ordinary shareholders' meeting – Article 231 § 1 k.s.h.), and within 15 days of approval they are filed with the KRS together with the resolution (Article 69(1)). Failure to file the financial statements in the register is a criminal offence punishable by a fine or restriction of liberty (Article 79(4)). After each change of shareholders, the management board files a new list of shareholders (Article 188 § 3 k.s.h.).

A separate obligation is to report the beneficial owner to the Central Register of Beneficial Owners (Centralny Rejestr Beneficjentów Rzeczywistych, CRBR) – within 14 days of the company's entry in the KRS and of each change, excluding Saturdays and public holidays (Article 60 of the Act on Counteracting Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing). Failure to do so is punishable by a financial penalty of up to PLN 1,000,000 (Article 153(1)).

Changes from 18 February 2027. The amendment to the k.s.h. of 23 January 2026 (Dz.U. 2026 poz. 176) changes, among other things, the rules on the register of shareholders in joint-stock companies and P.S.A.s (e.g. the management board will notify the registry court of the entity keeping the register); existing joint-stock companies, limited joint-stock partnerships and P.S.A.s have two years to adapt their statutes and articles of association.

Criminal liability of managers

The most common charge is mismanagement (niegospodarność) under Article 296 of the Criminal Code – causing substantial financial damage (over PLN 200,000) by abuse of powers or failure to perform a duty by a person handling the company's financial affairs; the basic offence is punishable by imprisonment from 3 months to 5 years. A person who, before criminal proceedings are initiated, has voluntarily remedied the damage in full is not punishable (Article 296 § 5). The Commercial Companies Code also has its own criminal provisions, e.g. Articles 586 and 587.

A final conviction for, among others, offences under Articles 587–5872 k.s.h. and under Chapters XXXIII–XXXVII of the Criminal Code (including mismanagement) disqualifies a person from serving as a management board member, supervisory board member or commercial proxy (prokurent) – as a rule, for five years from the judgment becoming final (Article 18 § 2–3 k.s.h.). We handle the defence in such cases as part of criminal law and, where taxes are involved, fiscal penal law.

Companies from Gdańsk and Pomerania

Our firm is located in Gdańsk at al. Grunwaldzka 87/91 lok. 10. Registrations of companies from the Tri-City and the surrounding area are handled by the 7th and 8th Commercial Divisions of the National Court Register of the District Court (Sąd Rejonowy) Gdańsk-Północ in Gdańsk, although applications are filed electronically anyway. Disputes over resolutions and larger corporate disputes are heard by the Regional Court (Sąd Okręgowy) in Gdańsk. We serve companies from the Tri-City and the whole of Pomerania and, remotely, also from other parts of Poland.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to set up a limited liability company via S24 or at a notary?

S24 is quicker and cheaper, but it allows only cash contributions, which must be made within seven days of registration, and only the provisions included in the template. Where there are several shareholders, someone is making a contribution in kind, or rules on the transfer of shares and on leaving the company are needed, we recommend articles of association in the form of a notarial deed.

As a management board member, am I liable for the company's debts?

Yes, if enforcement against the limited liability company proves ineffective (Article 299 k.s.h.). You can be released by showing, among other things, that the bankruptcy petition was filed in due time or that the failure to file it was not your fault. Similar rules apply to tax arrears and ZUS contributions.

How much time do I have to challenge a shareholders' resolution?

In a limited liability company, an action to set aside a resolution is brought within one month of receiving notice of it, but no later than six months from its adoption. An action for a declaration of invalidity – within six months of receiving notice, but no later than three years from the adoption of the resolution.

Does resigning from office protect me from liability?

Not with regard to the past. A former management board member is also liable for the company's tax arrears – for arrears whose payment deadline fell during his term of office (Article 116 § 2 and § 4 of the Tax Ordinance), and under Article 299 k.s.h. the courts also examine whether the obligation existed when the defendant was on the management board. Resignation therefore does not release you from liability for the period in office. If, as a result of the resignation, no seat on the management board would be filled, the resignation is submitted to the shareholders and a shareholders' meeting is convened at the same time (Article 202 § 6 k.s.h.).

How can I leave a limited liability company if the other shareholders do not want to buy my shares?

The options depend on the articles of association: selling the shares to a third party (with the company's consent, if required, which may be replaced by permission of the registry court), redemption of shares and, as a last resort, an action to dissolve the company for important reasons. The Code does not provide a general right to withdraw from a limited liability company along the lines of termination in a general partnership – which is why it is worth setting out exit rules in the articles of association.

Is a P.S.A. suitable for a start-up?

Often, yes: the minimum share capital is PLN 1, contributions may consist of work or services, and the rules for issuing shares are flexible. However, it requires a register of shareholders kept by a notary or an authorised entity (Article 30031 k.s.h.) and well-thought-out articles of association. We will gladly help you prepare them – please contact us.

Call: +48 790 377 775