al. Grunwaldzka 87/91 lok. 10, 80-244 Gdańsk +48 790 377 775 [email protected]
EN English

Education law – Teachers' Charter, employment matters

We assist teachers, head teachers and school governing authorities in matters under the Teachers' Charter and employment law: disciplinary proceedings, performance appraisals, promotion, pay and dismissals.

A teacher's employment relationship is governed by two acts at once: the Teachers' Charter (Karta Nauczyciela) and, in matters it does not regulate, the Labour Code (Kodeks pracy) (Article 91c(1) of the Teachers' Charter). On top of that come the Education Law Act (Prawo oświatowe) and regulations, e.g. on performance appraisal. That is why everyday questions – is the notice of termination lawful, how should overtime hours be calculated, was the performance appraisal issued correctly – require knowledge of several sets of provisions at the same time.

We assist teachers, head teachers and school governing authorities (organy prowadzące). On this page we describe the most common matters: disciplinary proceedings, performance appraisal, professional promotion, organisational changes, termination of employment and pay.

The basics: employment contract or appointment

A teacher's employment relationship is established on the basis of an employment contract or an appointment (mianowanie) (Article 10(1) of the Teachers' Charter). A beginning teacher is usually employed for a fixed term – for one school year (Article 10(2)). The current levels of professional promotion are appointed teacher (nauczyciel mianowany) and chartered teacher (nauczyciel dyplomowany) (Article 9a(1)). The form of employment and the promotion level determine, among other things, how the employment relationship can be terminated, what severance pay is due and how high the basic salary is.

Disputes concerning claims arising from teachers' employment relationships – irrespective of how the relationship was established – are heard by the labour courts (Article 91c(2)). Cases seeking a declaration that a notice of termination is ineffective and reinstatement fall within the jurisdiction of the District Courts (sądy rejonowe) regardless of the value of the subject matter of the dispute (Article 461 § 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure (k.p.c.)). A claim may be filed with the court competent for the employer or with the court in whose district the work is or was performed (Article 461 § 1 k.p.c.).

Disciplinary proceedings – step by step

Teachers are subject to disciplinary liability for conduct detrimental to the dignity of the profession or for breaching their duties as teachers (Article 75(1)). For breaches of work discipline, the head teacher may instead impose a disciplinary penalty under the Labour Code (Article 75(2)) – but not for an act infringing the rights and welfare of a child (Article 75(2a)).

The disciplinary penalties are: a reprimand with a warning, dismissal, dismissal with a ban on being employed in the profession for 3 years from the penalty, and expulsion from the profession (Article 76(1)). They are imposed by a disciplinary committee (Article 76(2)).

The proceedings usually run as follows:

  1. Notification of the disciplinary prosecutor (rzecznik dyscyplinarny) – where an act infringing the rights and welfare of a child is suspected, the head teacher notifies the disciplinary prosecutor within 14 days of becoming aware of it (Article 75(2a)).
  2. Explanatory proceedings – these are conducted by the disciplinary prosecutor, who notifies the teacher that they have been opened (Article 85(1) and (2)). The teacher has the right to a defence counsel (Article 85d(1)), may inspect the file and make copies (Article 85i(2)), and may give explanations and submit applications for evidence (Article 85g(1) and (3)). Within 3 months of opening the proceedings, the prosecutor files a motion to institute disciplinary proceedings or discontinues the proceedings (Article 85(3)).
  3. Institution of proceedings before the committee – at first instance, the case is decided by the disciplinary committee attached to the voivode (wojewoda), competent according to the teacher's place of employment at the time of the act (Article 77(1)(1)(a) and (2)) – for schools in our region, this is the committee attached to the Pomeranian Voivode (Wojewoda Pomorski). From the moment the decision to institute proceedings is served, the teacher becomes the accused (Article 85c(1)).
  4. Hearing – as a rule held in public (Article 85e(1)). The accused is not considered guilty until guilt has been established by a final ruling, and doubts that cannot be removed are resolved in the accused's favour (Article 85c(2) and (3)). The accused may have no more than two defence counsel of their choice (Article 85d(5)).
  5. Appeal – an appeal against a ruling of the first-instance committee may be lodged with the appellate disciplinary committee within 14 days of service of the ruling; lodging it suspends enforcement of the ruling (Article 85k(1)).
  6. Court – a final ruling of the appellate disciplinary committee may be appealed to the Court of Appeal (sąd apelacyjny) – labour and social security court competent for the accused's place of residence, within 14 days of service of the ruling with reasons (Article 85m(1)). No cassation appeal lies (Article 85m(2)).

Other important rules:

  • Limitation – disciplinary proceedings may not be instituted more than 5 months after the day on which the body attached to the committee learned of the act, or more than 2 years after it was committed (Article 85o(1)). In cases of sexual acts to the detriment of a minor, limitation may not occur before the victim reaches the age of 24 (Article 85o(2)).
  • Discontinuance – the teacher may lodge a complaint (zażalenie) against a decision discontinuing the explanatory proceedings within 7 days (Article 85(5)).
  • Suspension from duties – the head teacher may suspend a teacher against whom criminal proceedings have been instituted or a motion to institute disciplinary proceedings has been filed, and in cases concerning the rights and welfare of a child must, as a rule, do so (Article 85t(1) and (2)). During suspension, the basic salary may be reduced, and allowances and pay for overtime hours are not due; if the proceedings are discontinued for lack of evidence of guilt or the teacher is acquitted, the withheld part of the salary is repaid (Article 85u).
  • Expungement of the penalty – a reprimand with a warning and dismissal are expunged after 3 years, and dismissal with a ban on working in the profession – after 6 years from service of the final ruling (Article 85s(2)).
  • Reopening – proceedings concluded with a final ruling may be reopened in the cases set out in Article 85n.

Teacher performance appraisal

A performance appraisal (ocena pracy) is carried out on the head teacher's initiative or at the request of the teacher, the pedagogical supervision authority, the governing authority, the school council or the parents' council – as a rule not earlier than one year after the previous appraisal (Article 6a(1)). The head teacher has 3 months from the request or from notifying the teacher in writing that the appraisal has begun (Article 6a(2)); this period does not include, among other things, a longer justified absence and school holidays (Article 6a(2b)).

The appraisal is descriptive and ends with one of four conclusions: outstanding, very good, good or negative (Article 6a(4)). Before it is finalised, the teacher must be shown the draft and given the opportunity to submit comments and objections (Article 6a(8)). The appraisal form should include, among other things, reasons for the assessment under each criterion applied and information on the right of appeal (Article 6a(8a)). The appraisal may not be influenced by the teacher's religious beliefs or political views, or by a justified refusal to carry out an instruction contrary to the welfare of pupils or the public good (Article 6a(1g)).

Appeal – the teacher may lodge an appeal within 14 days of service of the appraisal, through the head teacher, with the pedagogical supervision authority (Article 6a(9)(1)) – in the Pomorskie Voivodeship, usually the Pomeranian Education Superintendent (Pomorski Kurator Oświaty). The appeal is considered by an appraisal panel which, at the teacher's request, includes a representative of a trade union designated by the teacher (Article 6a(9a)). Within 30 days, the authority upholds the appraisal, sets a new one, or annuls it and refers it for reassessment if it was issued in breach of the law (Article 6a(10a)). An appraisal set as a result of an appeal is final (Article 6a(10c)).

The stakes can be high: receiving a negative performance appraisal is one of the grounds for terminating the employment relationship of an appointed teacher (Article 23(1)(5)), and this provision also applies to teachers employed under an employment contract of indefinite duration (Article 27(3)). The appraisal also affects professional promotion. That is why an appeal should be prepared carefully – addressing each criterion and the evidence of the teacher's work.

Professional promotion

A beginning teacher completes a period of preparation for the profession, as a rule lasting 3 years and 9 months (Article 9ca(1)). The conditions for obtaining the level of appointed teacher include at least a good performance appraisal in the last year of preparation and passing an examination before an examination board (Article 9b(1)). The level of chartered teacher requires, among other things, at least a very good performance appraisal and approval by a qualification board (Article 9b(1a)).

For applications filed by 30 June, the authority issues a decision by 31 August, and for applications filed by 31 October – by 31 December (Article 9b(3) and (3a)). The level of appointed teacher is granted by the school's governing authority, and the level of chartered teacher by the pedagogical supervision authority, by way of an administrative decision (Article 9b(4)). A refusal is also issued as a decision (Article 9b(6)), which may be appealed under the rules of the Code of Administrative Procedure (Kodeks postępowania administracyjnego).

Note: the employment relationship of a teacher employed under a contract of indefinite duration terminates if, within 6 years of starting preparation for the profession, the teacher has not obtained the level of appointed teacher (Article 27(4)).

Organisational changes and termination of employment

School closure and organisational changes. If a school is closed down entirely, the head teacher terminates the employment relationship. In the event of a partial closure, a reduction in the number of classes or changes to the curriculum that make full-time employment impossible, the head teacher terminates the employment relationship or, at the teacher's request, transfers the teacher to inactive status (stan nieczynny) (Article 20(1)). Termination takes effect at the end of the school year, after three months' notice (Article 20(3)), subject to exceptions. An appointed teacher is entitled to severance pay equal to six months' basic salary (Article 20(2)). The notice is ineffective if the teacher, within 30 days of its service, submits a written request to be transferred to inactive status (Article 20(5c)). The head teacher notifies the trade union representing the teacher of the intention to give notice, and the union has 7 days to raise objections (Article 20(5a)).

Supplementing teaching hours and reducing employment. The governing authority may require a teacher to make up their teaching hours at another school to an extent not exceeding 1/2 of the compulsory teaching load (Article 22(1)). An appointed teacher may agree to a reduction of employment to not less than 1/2 of a full-time post with a proportionate reduction in pay (Article 22(2)).

Transfer. An appointed teacher may be transferred to another post or another school at their own request or ex officio with their consent (Article 18(1)).

Termination of a contract of indefinite duration takes effect at the end of the school year, with three months' notice (Article 27(1)). The employment relationship of an appointed teacher terminates, among other things, in the event of long-term incapacity for work (as a rule more than 182 days) or after a negative performance appraisal (Article 23(1)).

Deadline for going to court. An appeal against a notice of termination is lodged with the labour court within 21 days of service of the letter, and a claim for reinstatement following termination without notice – within 21 days of service of the notification (Article 264 §§ 1 and 2 of the Labour Code). The employer should state the reason for terminating the contract (Article 30 § 4 of the Labour Code). The court may rule that the notice is ineffective, order reinstatement or award compensation (Article 45 § 1 of the Labour Code).

Pay, overtime hours, leave

A teacher's remuneration consists of the basic salary, allowances (for length of service, a motivation allowance, a function allowance – including for acting as a form tutor – and an allowance for working conditions), pay for overtime hours and ad hoc cover, and bonuses and other benefits (Article 30(1)). A teacher may be required to work overtime hours not exceeding 1/4 of the weekly compulsory teaching load; more only with the teacher's consent and up to no more than 1/2 (Article 35(1)).

A teacher at a school with school holidays takes annual leave during the holidays; the head teacher may assign them certain tasks, which in total may not take more than 7 days (Article 64(1) and (2)). After 7 years of work at a school, a teacher employed full-time for an indefinite period may be granted health leave (urlop dla poratowania zdrowia) – of no more than one year at a time (Article 73(1)).

Claims arising from the employment relationship become time-barred, as a rule, 3 years after they fall due (Article 291 § 1 of the Labour Code) – so it is worth calculating and claiming unpaid allowances or overtime pay in good time.

For head teachers and governing authorities

The post of head teacher is entrusted by the school's governing authority (Article 63(1) of the Education Law Act). A head teacher may be removed from post, among other things, after a negative performance appraisal and, in particularly justified cases, also during the school year without notice, after consulting the education superintendent (kurator oświaty) (Article 66(1) of the Education Law Act). We advise head teachers and governing authorities on organisational changes, notices of termination, performance appraisals, disciplinary penalties, notifications to the disciplinary prosecutor and disputes before the labour court – so that staffing decisions comply with the procedure and are properly documented.

Most common mistakes

  • Missing the 14-day deadline for appealing against a performance appraisal or the 21-day deadline for appealing against a notice of termination.
  • Giving extensive explanations in the explanatory proceedings without having read the file.
  • Doing without a defence counsel at the disciplinary prosecutor stage – which is when the evidence is gathered.
  • Not submitting comments on the draft performance appraisal.
  • Failing to request transfer to inactive status within 30 days of notice given for organisational reasons, where the teacher wished to use this option.
  • On the school's side: failing to notify the trade union, or giving notice without stating the real reason.

What you can do yourself and when you need an advocate

You can: keep all letters with their dates of service, gather documentation of your work (plans, lesson scenarios, pupils' achievements, references), read the file, and ask your trade union for support. In the labour court, an employee can also bring a claim orally for the record (Article 466 k.p.c.). An advocate's help is particularly advisable in disciplinary proceedings, on termination of employment, in reinstatement cases and in appeals against a negative appraisal.

How we work

  1. We identify the deadlines that are already running and review the documents.
  2. We explain the possible scenarios and risks – including when a dispute is not worth pursuing.
  3. We prepare pleadings and attend examinations and hearings before the disciplinary committee and the labour court.
  4. We guarantee our clients discretion – we are bound by attorney–client privilege (tajemnica adwokacka).

Our firm operates in Gdańsk. We assist teachers and schools from the Tri-City and the surrounding area – from Gdańsk, Gdynia, Sopot, Pruszcz Gdański, Rumia, Reda, Wejherowo, Kartuzy, Żukowo, Tczew and Starogard Gdański – as well as from other towns in the Pomorskie Voivodeship. Consultations can take place at our office, by telephone or online – details on the contact page. You can find the text of the Act on our website: Teachers' Charter.

Frequently asked questions

I have received notice of explanatory proceedings. What should I do?

Do not ignore it, and do not give explanations straight away "in the heat of the moment". You have the right to a defence counsel already at this stage and the right to inspect the file (Article 85d(1) and Article 85i(2) of the Teachers' Charter). It is best first to learn the allegation and the evidence, and then to prepare explanations and applications for evidence.

How long do I have to appeal against a performance appraisal?

14 days from service of the appraisal. The appeal is lodged through the head teacher with the pedagogical supervision authority (Article 6a(9)).

Can I go to court against a ruling of the disciplinary committee?

Yes. A final ruling of the appellate disciplinary committee may be appealed to the Court of Appeal – labour and social security court, within 14 days of service of the ruling with reasons (Article 85m(1)).

Does a disciplinary penalty stay on file forever?

No. A reprimand with a warning and dismissal are expunged after 3 years, and dismissal with a ban on working in the profession – after 6 years, unless the teacher is penalised again during that time (Article 85s(2) and (3)). Expulsion from the profession is not expunged.

The school is reducing the number of classes. Can they dismiss me?

Yes, but only under the rules in Article 20 of the Teachers' Charter: at the end of the school year, after three months' notice, with the involvement of the trade union. You have 30 days to request transfer to inactive status and 21 days to appeal to the labour court. It is also worth checking whether the head teacher selected the teacher to be dismissed correctly.

The board refused my promotion. Can I appeal?

A refusal to grant a promotion level is issued by way of an administrative decision (Article 9b(6)), so it can be appealed to the higher-level authority, followed by a complaint to the administrative court. It is worth checking whether the examination or qualification procedure was conducted in accordance with the rules.

Do you also represent schools?

Yes. We advise head teachers and governing authorities – we do not, however, act against a client we already represent in the same or a related matter.

Call: +48 790 377 775