al. Grunwaldzka 87/91 lok. 10, 80-244 Gdańsk +48 790 377 775 [email protected]
EN English

Transport law – carriage of goods, fuel sector

We advise transport, freight forwarding, rail and fuel companies: contracts of carriage and freight forwarding, cargo damage, freight charge disputes, penalties after inspections, URE licences and excise duty.

Transport and fuel are sectors in which high turnover goes hand in hand with dense regulation: contracts of carriage and freight forwarding, liability for consignments, roadside inspections, licences, concessions, excise duty and the monitoring of the carriage of goods. On this page we describe what typical cases of carriers, freight forwarders, logistics operators, rail companies, fuel wholesalers and filling stations look like – and where problems most often arise.

We help both with day-to-day legal services (contracts, general terms and conditions, claims procedures) and in disputes: cargo damage, unpaid freight charges, a penalty imposed after an inspection, or proceedings before the President of the Energy Regulatory Office (Prezes URE).

Contracts of carriage and freight forwarding – where to start

Under a contract of carriage, the carrier undertakes, within the scope of its business, to carry persons or goods for remuneration (Article 774 of the Civil Code (k.c.)). A freight forwarder, by contrast, undertakes to dispatch or collect a consignment or to provide other services connected with its carriage, and may act in its own name or in the name of the principal (Article 794 k.c.). This distinction matters in practice: the freight forwarder is liable for the carriers and further forwarders it uses, unless it is not at fault in selecting them (Article 799 k.c.).

Domestic carriage is governed primarily by the Transport Law (Prawo przewozowe), and the provisions of the Civil Code apply only insofar as the carriage in question is not regulated separately (Article 775 k.c.). The international carriage of goods by road is governed by the CMR Convention.

A good transport order or framework agreement should clearly specify:

  • who is the carrier and who is the freight forwarder – and whether subcontracting is permitted,
  • the place and date of loading and unloading, the type of goods, their value and requirements (temperature, ADR, securing),
  • the amount of the freight charge, the payment deadline and the conditions for charging additional costs (waiting time, downtime, additional unloading),
  • contractual penalties – for what, in what amount and subject to what cap,
  • the rules for notifying damage and claims,
  • the required carrier's or freight forwarder's liability insurance,
  • the governing law and the court with jurisdiction over disputes.

We draft and review contracts of carriage, freight forwarding and logistics agreements, and general terms of cooperation. We write about contracts in more detail on the civil-law contracts page.

Damage to a consignment – step by step

The carrier is liable for the loss of, shortage in or damage to the consignment from the moment it is accepted for carriage until it is delivered, and for delay (Article 65(1) of the Transport Law). It is released from liability if it shows, among other things, that the damage was caused by the sender or the consignee, by the nature of the goods or by force majeure – the burden of proof lies with the carrier (Article 65(2)). In domestic carriage, the steps usually look like this:

  1. On delivery – if a shortage or damage is visible, we demand that the condition of the consignment be established in a formal report (Article 74 of the Transport Law). We also enter remarks on the consignment note. Accepting the consignment without reservations, as a rule, extinguishes claims for shortage or damage (Article 76 of the Transport Law; similarly Article 791 § 1 k.c.).
  2. Hidden damage – if the damage could not be seen from the outside, within 7 days of accepting the consignment you must demand that its condition be established and prove that the damage occurred during carriage (Article 76(4) of the Transport Law). The Civil Code provides for a one-week period for notifying the carrier (Article 791 § 1 k.c.).
  3. Documentation – photographs, the report, documents showing the value of the goods (invoice), correspondence, data from the temperature recorder or GPS.
  4. Claim – in cases under the Transport Law, a lawsuit against the carrier may be filed only after the claims procedure has been exhausted without success. A claim is deemed unsuccessful if the carrier has not paid within 3 months of its service (Article 75(1) and (2)).
  5. Amount of compensation – for loss or shortage, it is determined according to the price shown on the invoice and, failing that, according to the price list or the value of goods of the same kind (Article 80(1) of the Transport Law). The Civil Code limits compensation to the ordinary value of the consignment, unless the damage resulted from the carrier's wilful misconduct or gross negligence (Article 788 § 1 k.c.).
  6. Lawsuit – if the carrier or its insurer does not pay.

Watch the limitation periods. Claims under the Transport Law are, as a rule, time-barred after one year, and claims for delay that did not cause a shortage or damage – 2 months after delivery of the consignment (Article 77(1) and (2)). The Civil Code also lays down a one-year period for the carriage of goods (Article 792 k.c.) and for freight forwarding (Article 803 k.c.). Recourse claims between carriers are time-barred 6 months after the damage has been made good or after the action was brought (Article 78(1) of the Transport Law, Article 793 k.c.); a similar rule applies to the freight forwarder's claims against carriers and further forwarders (Article 804 k.c.).

International carriage – the CMR Convention

In the international carriage of goods by road, the carrier's liability is governed by the CMR Convention. The carrier is liable for loss, damage and delay, but its liability for loss or damage is limited – compensation may not exceed 8.33 units of account (SDR) per kilogram of gross weight short (Article 23(3) CMR as amended by the 1978 Protocol). The Convention does, however, provide for exceptions to this limit in cases of qualified fault on the part of the carrier, which is why establishing how the damage occurred is often key in CMR disputes.

The CMR lays down its own short time limits for making reservations on delivery and for pursuing claims – shorter than the general civil-law periods – as well as its own rules on jurisdiction. In the event of damage in international carriage, it is worth contacting a lawyer even before sending the first letter to the carrier: whether the claim survives depends on the proper wording of the reservations and the claim.

Freight charge disputes and recovery of receivables

The most common dispute in the sector is an unpaid freight charge – or, from the other side, the set-off of the freight charge against a contractual penalty or compensation. Before filing a lawsuit, it is worth establishing:

  • whether the contract and documents (order, CMR note, proof of delivery) confirm that the carriage was performed,
  • whether the principal has made a claim, notified damage or charged a penalty – and whether it did so in accordance with the contract,
  • whether the claim is close to becoming time-barred – in carriage, the time limits are short.

In cases under the Transport Law, the carrier too may go to court only after an unsuccessful demand for payment addressed to the obligor (Article 75(1)). A dispute between businesses within the scope of their business activity is a commercial case (Article 4582 § 1 point 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (k.p.c.)). In such a case, the claimant must put forward all allegations and evidence in the statement of claim, and the defendant in the statement of defence; late ones are, as a rule, disregarded (Article 4585 § 1 and 4 k.p.c.). The statement of claim must therefore be complete from the outset. Property cases in which the value of the claim exceeds 100,000 zł are heard at first instance by the Regional Court (sąd okręgowy) (Article 17 point 4 k.p.c.). An action for performance of a contract or for damages for its non-performance may also be brought before the court for the place of performance of the contract (Article 34 § 1 k.p.c.).

More about recovering receivables on the debt collection and litigation pages.

Roadside inspections and penalties for carriers

For performing road transport in breach of obligations or conditions of carriage, the Road Transport Act (ustawa o transporcie drogowym) provides for a financial penalty of 50 zł to 12,000 zł for each infringement, and the total of penalties for infringements found during a single roadside inspection may not, as a rule, exceed 12,000 zł (Article 92a(1) and (3)) – subject to the exceptions specified in the Act. The transport manager and other persons performing activities connected with carriage are liable separately (Article 92a(2)).

The penalty is imposed by way of an administrative decision by the authority whose employees or officers found the infringement (Article 93(1)). In the defence, the following are particularly relevant:

  • for infringements of driving and rest times – showing that the company ensured proper organisation and discipline of work and proper rules for remunerating drivers (Article 92b(1)),
  • showing that the carrier had no influence over the occurrence of an infringement that resulted from events it could not foresee (Article 92c(1)(1)),
  • the lapse of more than 2 years since the infringement was discovered (Article 92c(1)(3)).

An appeal lies against the decision, followed by a complaint to the administrative court; if a complaint is lodged, the authority of its own motion suspends enforcement of the final decision (Article 93(2)). We describe the general rules of proceedings before public authorities on the representation before public authorities page.

Carriers and senders of sensitive goods are also subject to obligations under the Act on the System for Monitoring the Road and Rail Carriage of Goods and Trading in Heating Fuels (the so-called SENT system). We assist in cases concerning penalties for breach of these obligations.

Rail transport

Licences for railway undertakings are granted by the President of the Office of Rail Transport (Prezes Urzędu Transportu Kolejowego, UTK) by way of an administrative decision; a licence is a permit within the meaning of the Entrepreneurs' Law (Prawo przedsiębiorców) (Article 45 of the Rail Transport Act (ustawa o transporcie kolejowym)). We advise railway undertakings and other rail market participants on applications for a licence and for its amendment, on matters of access to infrastructure and on agreements with infrastructure managers. In some market regulation matters, an appeal against a decision of the President of UTK lies to the Court of Competition and Consumer Protection (Sąd Ochrony Konkurencji i Konsumentów) within 14 days (Article 13b(2)); in others, the administrative route applies.

Fuel sector

URE licences. Trading in fuels requires a licence from the President of URE (Article 32(1)(4) of the Energy Law (Prawo energetyczne), with the exceptions specified in the Act), as do the storage and transhipment of liquid fuels. Trading in liquid fuels with foreign countries requires financial security of 10,000,000 zł (Article 38a(1)). The President of URE may change the terms of a licence and, in the cases specified in the Act, withdraws it (Article 41). Financial penalties are provided for infringements (Article 56). An appeal against a decision of the President of URE is lodged with the Regional Court in Warsaw (Sąd Okręgowy w Warszawie) – the Court of Competition and Consumer Protection – within 14 days (Article 30(2)).

Excise duty and audits. Trading in fuels involves excise duty settlements, excise security and tax warehouses. Audits in this area are usually carried out by the bodies of the National Revenue Administration (Krajowa Administracja Skarbowa, KAS). After a customs and tax audit there are 14 days to file a corrected tax return (Article 82(3) of the National Revenue Administration Act (ustawa o KAS)) – this is the moment when decisions have to be taken quickly and deliberately.

Fiscal penal liability. The Fiscal Penal Code (k.k.s.) penalises, among other things, infringements in trading in excise goods (Article 63 k.k.s.) and acquiring, storing or transporting excise goods derived from such acts (Article 65 k.k.s.). It is also an offence to acquire or transport such goods when, on the basis of the accompanying circumstances, one could and should have suspected that they derived from an offence (Article 65 § 2 k.k.s.) – which is why verifying the counterparty and the origin of the fuel is not a formality. We describe the defence on the Fiscal Penal Code page.

Contracts. We draft fuel supply, storage and transhipment agreements, agreements with filling station tenants and franchise agreements – with an emphasis on allocating licensing and excise obligations and liability for fuel quality.

Most common mistakes

  • Accepting goods without reservations despite visible damage to the packaging.
  • No claim filed with the carrier before a lawsuit in a case under the Transport Law.
  • Overlooking the one-year or two-month limitation period.
  • Transport orders without clear rules on contractual penalties and set-offs – the dispute then concerns not the damage, but the interpretation of an e-mail.
  • Failing to vet subcontractors and fuel counterparties.
  • An appeal against a URE decision sent to the wrong court or out of time.

What you can do yourself, and when you need an advocate

You can yourself secure evidence on delivery, draw up a damage report, gather invoices and correspondence and send the carrier a notice of damage. An advocate is useful for high-value claims, CMR carriage, disputes over freight charges and contractual penalties, appeals against administrative penalties, licensing matters and any matter carrying a fiscal penal risk.

How we work

  1. At the first meeting we establish the facts, the deadlines and the documents that need to be secured.
  2. We assess the legal basis: the Transport Law, the Civil Code, the CMR, the Road Transport Act, the Energy Law.
  3. We prepare the claim, demand for payment, appeal or statement of claim – and continue to handle the matter if the client so wishes.
  4. In an ongoing relationship, we review template orders, general terms and claims procedures so that future disputes are simpler or do not arise at all.

Our office is in Gdańsk on al. Grunwaldzka. We work with transport, freight forwarding and fuel companies from the Tricity and Pomerania – including Gdańsk, Gdynia, Sopot, Pruszcz Gdański, Tczew, Starogard Gdański, Rumia, Reda and Wejherowo. We handle cases before the President of URE, the President of UTK and the court in Warsaw regardless of where the client is based. A meeting can be arranged via the contact page.

Frequently asked questions

I accepted the goods and only saw the damage after unpacking them. Can I still do anything?

Yes, but you need to act quickly. In domestic carriage, within 7 days of accepting the consignment you must demand that its condition be established and show that the damage occurred during carriage (Article 76(4) of the Transport Law). In international carriage, the time limits under the CMR Convention apply – and they are also short.

How much compensation is payable in international carriage?

As a rule, no more than 8.33 SDR per kilogram of gross weight short (Article 23(3) CMR), unless the exceptions provided for in the Convention apply. For light and expensive goods, this limit can be much lower than the value of the cargo – which is why it is worth considering additional insurance or a declaration of value.

A customer is not paying the freight charge because it claims the goods arrived damaged. What next?

You need to establish whether the damage was notified on time and in the form required by the contract and the law, and whether the contract allows a set-off. The dispute over the freight charge and the dispute over the damage are often resolved in a single case. Remember that in domestic carriage claims are, as a rule, time-barred after one year.

Do I have to file a claim with the carrier before suing it?

In cases under the Transport Law – yes. A lawsuit may be filed after the claims procedure has been exhausted without success, i.e. if the carrier has not paid within 3 months of service of the claim (Article 75(1) and (2)).

I have received a penalty decision after a roadside inspection. Is it worth appealing?

Often yes, especially where the infringement resulted from circumstances beyond the company's control, or in the case of infringements of drivers' working time where the company can show proper organisation of work (Articles 92b and 92c of the Road Transport Act). The assessment should be made immediately after the decision is served, because the deadlines for an appeal are short.

Do you help with obtaining a fuel trading licence?

Yes. We prepare the application and documents, handle contact with URE during the proceedings, and later assist with changes to the licence and in inspection or penalty proceedings.

Freight forwarder or carrier – who is liable for the damage?

That depends on the content of the contract and the role the company actually performed. The carrier is liable for the consignment from acceptance to delivery, and the freight forwarder for the choice of the carrier and further forwarders (Article 799 k.c.), unless it has itself assumed the obligations of a carrier. In practice, both entities are often sued, or claims are directed to their insurers.

Call: +48 790 377 775